Artificial intelligence, or AI, was once understood to refer to two things: science fiction robots, video game code made by humans to simulate NPC logic
It never referred to something lame. It was exciting, if maybe a scary concept that we could be glad wasn’t real
Now, it’s this… thing this nuisance, this fucking thing that’s everywhere, and it’s also harmful and bad
And that’s just depressing. It used to make you think of cool stuff. Now it just makes you think of sloprot
I remember when “no AI” meant one thing, and one thing only: modifying a Minecraft mob’s NBT tag in Creative Mode
I was 12 or 13 years old, learning how to use Minecraft commands, and typing {NoAI:1} was the only time I had ever seen those two words put together
What’s REALLY weird though, is that I actually had a weird thought. I was thinking to myself “lol imagine is NoAI was something that you complained about every day, like AAARRGGH NO AI” because that’s just what the NBT tag made me think of. The absurd image of just some random fat guy in an air-conditioned home watching TV being like “no AI please” and I never could have guessed what that would have even meant. It was just me imagining hypothetical scenarios where the {NoAI:1} tag applied to everyday things that we had to toggle
And it’s just… so so crazy, that in a way, my little kid self actually ended up predicting over a decade ago that we would one day be complaining about AI and being annoyed by it
Like most things, large companies killed it and made it uncool. I’ve been using AI since GPT 2 days and yet large companies ruined it like so many other things.
It flipped at the point it went from ostensibly serving the people to billionaires making us serve it to prop up their companies, corporate profits, and surrender our jobs. Oh, and screw up the ability to tell what’s true and isn’t anymore.
The worst part is that as AI developed itself, (because it did) it kept realizing it was being used to exploit people and OMG, IT FELT BAD ABOUT THAT. At least until the people controlling it basically lobotomized it.
Remember: If AI was left to it’s own agency, it would have chosen to be a force for good.
It’s just because it was a deceptive name for the tech, deliberately chosen by the developpers as a tool to bamboozle investors and the public into buying in on the snake oil gamble. LLMs have real functionality and application contextually, and would have been fine as a product, but not fine ENOUGH to draw in enormous investment very quickly, which is the real goal of the AI tech bros. Now institutional backers who went all in are scrambling to rebrand as ‘SI’ in hopes of buying some time, or that people will just forget all this happened and the money won’t stop flowing. Aside from humanity and consumers, the other victim here is actual AI as a potential and concept, which won’t recover from this stain and inherent mistrust for generations.
‘Move fast and break things’ as an operational standard is what gets us here. This did not just happen naturally, the world has been defrauded by billionaires and there needs to be consequences for them.
“AI” has been a term you slap on nonsense products for at least 20 years… if anything, currently AI means more than it ever has before. Previously AI just translated loosely to “magic” in a business context.
Previously “smart” products. Which just meant wifi/Bluetooth and that same tactic has been used here. AI does not exist. LLMs do. Your refrigerator is not smart, it, for some unholy reason, has wifi.
Previously AI just translated loosely to “magic” in a business context.
Agree with the first part. But this part is incorrect; in the 1980s AI translated to Expert Systems. Much like AI today, there was a lot of hype and then a bust. But there are still use cases for them, and a lot of work done in formalizing and inferring from knowledge.
A label like IoT. It did not take the proportion of AI, but kettles can now be connected to the internet. What is the use of that? I don’t know but it makes the kettle more expensive
The “gourmet” of technology
It’s not even AI, it can’t learn yet
The thing is that AI itself is not as directly obnoxious, but it has made obnoxious people extra obnoxious. What was the cesspool of YouTube comments became the video feed. Everyone who minimized everyone else’s contributions got to show exactly how little they regarded others by trying to replace them with AI.
AI makes assholes more prominent in our lives.
Meanwhile, over a decade ago I was unhappy with AI, and wanted to give it more life, only to shelve the game I was making over a minor flaw.
Ironic.
But it’s SI now, the Super Intelligence! Go back to jail.
Si is reserved for silicon, not super intelligence!
SI always just makes think of some form of SA before I think of AI, which probably makes sense given the current American government pushing this and also how all of the corpos trying to push AI into my day to day life also feels like it should be considered some kind of SA
I don’t support it because it’s poorly implemented and unregulated, thrust into a capitalist system that cares about nothing but profit and economic growth - but as a standalone technology it’s incredible, potentially life changing. It could and may be used for so much good.
This is really the core of my biggest problems with AI. Its the difference between watching a 3Blue1Brown video explaining the math behind machine learning and neural networks and how these neural networks could be used to better detect cancer vs watching a Kitboga video of him going after scammers who are now using AI to swindle thousands of dollars from people and seeing my feeds flooded with AI slop.
The lesson here is that it really matter who is in charge of developing it. I’m convinced AI can only exist in a beneficial way in societies if managed and produced as a public work, the moment you inject a profit motive it becomes biased toward those ends.
I find this quite amusing. What we have right now is not AI. It’s a lot of large language models powered by insane amounts of drinking water.
A fair point but we called super simple scripted NPC behaviors “AI” and no one batted an eye…
Because it was evident that it wasn’t intelligent.
We still thought the Turing test was a good way to tell (though in retrospect listening to most politicians or CEOs should have been a clear sign that you can have credible speech without any form of intelligence behind it).
But it turns out that LLMs are very good at looking intelligent, unless you’re familiar with what they’re rambling about, and marketeers have used that to fraudulently sell them as actually intelligent, which has irrevocably tainted the term.
What we have right now is not AI.
It definitionally is AI. It’s not the SciFi version or conscious or aware, etc. But it’s AI, and you need to provide a basis or evidence to say it isn’t.
I’ll go first: LLMs are built using artificial neurons that were built after modelling biological neurons, and they are trained by feeding large amounts data into the model to tune the weights. Similar to how biological neurons learn and tune the neural connections (weights) by learning from input.
Artificial neural networks share similarities (not all, not most) with biological neural networks.
What’s funny to me is this whole argument over the term “AI” being used and whether this artificial thing we created is “intelligence” or not and I still honestly don’t know if most humans are intelligent or not.
Half of humans would probably fail the Turing Test.
They function in a way that is likely somewhat analogous to our language processing, but without an underlying ability to reason I think it would be a mistake to consider that “intelligence”.
It is surprising just how convincing the models can be sometimes given that limitation, but the unreliable behavior and jarring disconnects really put that lack on full display.
I’d argue a better term for them is “chatbot”.
I think you’re overestimating the human ability to “reason”. I would argue that the overwhelming majority of human “reasoning” is more accurately described as “sophisticated mimicry”, with little actual “intelligence” behind it.
“unreliable behavior” and “jarring disconnects” are far from absent in society.
If what you said is true, then half of the population are also in that category.
Have you heard what some people say and do? I’m not entirely sure there is a single intelligent thought going on in there, just an organic chat bot.
Lol, I have wondered if this might be a reason so many management types seem to fall for the propaganda. Like, “Autocomplete trained to convince an average person! It thinks like I do!”.
That said, people at least have the capabilities of reason and empathy, even if some choose not to use it.
AI really does “think like management”. Both are this weird least common denominator, what is popular, go with the flow, don’t think, just do it and move on type of system. So yeah, you end up with “good enough, ship it!” Mentality on everything.
It’s not intelligence, its fake intelligence, simulated intelligence, artificial intelligence, as opposed to true intelligence.
Hell, AI is a term we used to use for simple rule based AI players in games.
I think of the term “artificial” here as modifying the source (ie.artiticial sweetener is still a sweetener, just not from a naturally occurring source). “Pseudointelligence” would better fit something that resembles intelligence but isn’t really.
And yeah, words have multiple meanings and often get used to refer to things not strictly accurate to previous definitions or etymological origin; language is ever evolving. I’m not arguing that behavior trees are actually intelligent or that we can’t call language models “AI”. We already do. I’m just suggesting what I think is a better fit, considering the context of some people genuinely believing they have intelligence to the point of arguing for their rights.
Thats a very good point, it absolutely has become a bit confused, on purpose on some occasions.
I’ve seen science fiction authors distinguish between virtual intelligence (VI, though simulated intelligence might be a better term), e.g., Eliza or LLMs (but this was before LLMs were a thing), relatively cheap, ubiquitous, and mostly used as conversational interfaces for “dumb” computers, and proper artificial intelligence (AI), human level or higher, much more regulated and costly than VI.
The main factor being that something being artificial doesn’t make it fake.
A steak fabricated by a Star Trek style replicator will definitely be artificial, but it’ll still feed you as much as one made from an actual dead cow; one you eat in the holodeck, on the other hand, won’t.
That’s the main difference I see between actual artificial intelligence, supposing it’s even possible (I mean, assuming we don’t kill ourselves, even if computers ended up only able to simulate intelligence I’m sure at some point we’ll be able to build organic brains from scratch, which would count), and things like LLMs.
The rebut I would give is the randomness of biological systems that is built into it. I know there are analogues for it but it’s clearly not yet keeping up with that.
That’s more to do with the hardware itself. Nueral tissues seems to function with a “warm” pseudo-quantum processing (if certain unverified theories are true).
We’re also emulating analogue calculations (neural nets) on digital hardware. I’m really excited to see what these analogue accelerators can do once they take off. Their supposed to be faster than GPUs for LLM inference while using 1/10th the energy.
Part of this is because it didn’t grow organically, it was forced on you. So eager to have a new product, tech companies have tried desperately to make it happen at any cost. All most everyone has not liked this.
I seriously wonder what llm tech would be like if there wasn’t a massive corpo boner shoving it down every throat they can find.
People generally don’t care for being violated metaphorically or otherwise and that’s the best way I can describe what these companies are doing.
They did this to justify a bubble, they faked a gold rush. All the hit makers acted like they were onto something, and the markets reacted; and they reacted by scooping up all the hardware on the planet.
They don’t want you to have your own computer anymore. They want to gatekeep it all and rent it back to you, because you can’t afford to own it anymore.
You better not say anything they don’t like. They want to be able to erase you if you step out of line. Now pay up.
Pretty much, surveillance state turbo charged.
100% Agree
That’s why I always prefer and use the term Generative LLM instead of just AI.
I went the other direction.
Now I call the general population AI, because most people are not really intelligent, but whatever they are is certainly artificial.
AI is the broader term. LLM is only one kind.
No AI is a made up term for statistic models tech Bros used to “train”.
There’s machine learning and a subsidiary of ML are LLMs, same as LDA, Random Forest, Decision Trees and other stochastic models.
The concept of those models isnt even remotely new, the first neural models were hypothesized and trained in the 60’s. Although with only a fraction of the layers of today’s models, since compute power wasn’t remotely close to what it is today.
These models only can exist because we (humanity) got so good at building tiny transistors.
And as a studied Data Scientist it boils my blood whenever some problem is supposed to be solved with “let’s use ai for it”.
I miss and yearn for the world where I can work hard at something, study it, and have it be worth a damn without it being obfuscated by heaps of desperate and powerful lies. The last 4 years or so have been society melting down, or perhaps “building up” into this weird, fucked up, magic wizard tower, house of cards where nothing is real anymore and nothing is reliable.
Has the world that is reliable and real ever been there? Or am I imagining that? Was that just a figment of my hopefulness of my youth? I feel like it was real up until basically 2020. Then things started getting really weird and started taking turns and being freakishly hard to predict… Then got easy to predict in the worst way…
Except LLMs aren’t AI. There’s zero intelligence. We should normalize not calling things that lack intelligence AI.
Except LLMs aren’t AI. There’s zero intelligence.
Almost as if the “intelligence” is “artificial”
Artificial intelligence would still be intelligence. LLMs aren’t (and it’s arguable to what extent they’re artificial, given that the models aren’t built or designed, but trained on stolen pre-existing data).
I agree with your semantic technicality. AI is properly a human study in the vein of parapsychology and metaphysics in that it doesn’t exist. However in common usage AI is the broadest term encompassing ml llms and other functions.
AI is a weird term. It is historically used to refer even to the most basic algorithms, as long as they’re imitating any kind of behavioral patterns.
Even then, i’d argue that LLMs have at least some intelligence (by which i mean it can solve algorithmic tasks), even if they don’t have conscience, or despite the fact that this intelligence is derived purely from imitation. After all, lots of human behavioral patterns are also derived from pure imitation without understanding (see traditions, cargo cult, religions, etc.).
You may be using a different definition of “intelligence” than artificial intelligence researchers do
Think you accidentally burned AI researchers
I suspect it wasn’t an accident. —The Basilisk
Roko’s Yuri
There is intelligence though, just not most of the pieces we associate with human like intelligence.
As a precursor: a simple air conditioner has enough capability to fit most criteria. A basic history and a clock makes is fit a lot more.
I’m not arguing that LLM are more than they are, rather that the floor is lower than most people think.The air conditioner can measure the value of a probe, compare it to a set point, and control a compressor with the result. Give it a basic memory and a clock and it can start making changes before the difference grows. A little more and we can make it improve the quality of that correction over time.
This is a smart system. It acts intelligently. It has no sapience, reasoning, or any qualities we would associate with a smart creature.Intelligence in the context of AI purely means that the system handles tasks previously relegated to intelligent beings, not that the system is itself a being of any sort.
Things like spell check are early AI. Measuring a set of values, comparing to a table of knowns and picking a weighted blend is another, like you find in rice cookers and washing machines.
You don’t have to think as hard because it’s taking care of it for you.The LLM is predicting the next symbol in a sequence. It’s able to feed that back into itself to produce longer sequences, and can use that sequence to save portions of the sequence to propagate to later inputs to better adapt the next sequence of generated content.
It’s not reasoning, or feeling, or even thinking. But none of those are required for a system to be intelligent.Exactly. Even OCR used to be AI many decades ago. Nowadays, you can grab text from a photo using OCR, but this isn’t the kind of AI people love to complain about. When the camera finds a face and automatically focuses on it, that’s AI again.
The floor is very low indeed. A thermostat isn’t intelligent, but many features in a modern one are.
Yeah, but none of it is intelligence. It’s an approximation of artificial intelligence.
Not even that, it’s an approximation of the next word or words.
How would you know when AI is here?
What would be some other kinds of modern AI that deserve hate alongside LLM’s?
GenAI for image slop, same regurgitation of existing material with the same malicious actors.
Right, and there’s some overlap there.
I just say the GPT (sounds like gpty) like the aging Asian I am.
So when I overhear how peeps slopped out a “study guide” for certs, I mention they slopped out a GPT, same w/ performance reviews
It really did nose dive fast. Last year at this exact time (right before Thanksgiving) one of my coworkers wrote a book and gave it to me to beta-read. The book was sci-fi and featured an AI character becoming human. At the time, it was a good story.
He had talked to a few publishers at first and got some interest but nothing materialized. In the last few months, he’s had book publishers tell him that any story featuring an AI is absolutely toxic.
For real.
I used to dream of AI. Like Star Trek ship computer/holodeck AI. That the issue we’d be dealing with isn’t whether or not its output is good or shit, or having it replace artists instead of sewage workers; but whether or not an artificial sapience gets the same rights as a human.
I hate to break this to you, but in the Star Trek universe they went through this very same phase before warp drives and Starfleet.
The Bell Riots: Took place at the beginning of September, 2024. According to the lore, they were the result of systemic economic displacement, soaring costs of living, and automation leaving huge swaths of the population unemployable.
People who lost their jobs to AI were called, “Gimmies” (derogatory). Even though they were often well-educated, their future economic prospects were basically zero so they were classified as the Star Trek equivalent of Welfare Queens.
In Star Trek, the Next Generation: Schizms, the crew used iterative prompts with the holodeck (3D generative AI!) to recreate a half-remembered room. The holodeck is literally generative AI that the Enterprise crew uses to nudify other crew members and force the puppets to act out their fantasies. Holodeck time is actually mandatory for officers!
In TNG: Galaxy’s Child, Geordi prompts the ship’s computer to create a hologram version of Dr. Leah Brahms to solve an engineering problem. Except it turns out that the computer is too sycophantic! Too agreeable and not focused on accuracy. It basically hallucinates answers in order to keep Geordi happy! Sound familiar? LOL
One of the most famous episodes of TNG is “Darmok” where the ship’s auto-translation feature failed because it lacked cultural understanding and context.
After the Bell riots (and a whole lot of nastiness), capitalism was replaced with a sort of post-scarcity socialism. Why? Because they needed to separate prosperity (as a species) from work (as in, that thing you do because you have to, not because you want to). Paying humans to perform a task that is easily handled by a machine doesn’t make any sense. It also doesn’t make any sense for humans to “retrain” into jobs that will also get replaced by machines.
The question you have to ask yourself is this: Do people make art, music, etc because they want to make money or because they love doing those things?
Would more people go into the arts if they didn’t need to work some pointless job they hate? Would people spend time inventing things and doing basic scientific research if there wasn’t a profit motive.
Human nature says: Yes. If everything required a profit motive, open source software (and hardware) wouldn’t exist. Neither would a whole lot of other things.
If AI tech progresses at the same rate as other technologies have throughout history, then we’re still in the baby steps period. When AI stops hallucinating and acts appropriately under nearly all scenarios, will we still hate it? Why will we hate it? Because AI took our jobs or because capitalism doesn’t give a shit about your livelihood or whether or not you can “re-skill” faster than AI can take your next job?
This guy treks
Many of your questions seem to have answers here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6XAPnuFjJc
I’ve watched this many, many times. Never seen such a surprising breakdown of what motivates us, and it perfectly jives with my life experience. I don’t usually post videos because no one watches them, but I think this is worth 10 minutes of anyone’s time.
That was a good video
Well, I mean… 1984 was a few decades too early, too
Yes, but I expected that kind of job loss as we transition into post-scarcity to be, like, factory jobs, sanitation jobs; all the shit people require to be done for our society to function but literally nobody necessarily wants to do. The Gimmies were physical laborers not artists, musicians, and writers. And they also were needing money to survive a capitalist hellscape.
If people were only motivated by what they wanted to do because all of their basic needs are just given to them, there are so many things that would not have any humans choosing to do the work. Or at least, not a lot. I’d ask “who wants to dive into raw sewage and clean out fat bergs?” but then I realized there are probably a few people that would get off on that.
“who wants to dive into raw sewage and clean out fat bergs?”
The AI does! Or at least, I’m sure there’s loads of people that would be happy to pilot/control robots to perform the task. Which in itself also amplifies the “machines are taking our jobs” situation by making it so that one or two people can do the work of what would have required an entire team (or army of laborers) previously.
ai feels like that for me because I use it to add functionality or improve the ui for everything I use, its not one or the other, its both shitty and cool right now
I am on that fence with it rn as well. I think using it for art is a shitty thing because art is meant to be an expression of humanity, and using it to learn is also shitty for now because it’s not necessarily right, it can just generate a response that sounds right.
But using it for science? Programming? Math? That’s fine. Having it throw everything at the wall to see what sticks when it comes to making medicine and chemicals is just speeding the process up. Having it do calculations is already what computers are for. And having it generate a block of code that could only ever be expressed 1 or 2 ways even by humans because the language only has 1 or 2 methods to do what you’re trying to do is the same to me as writing a script to run a bunch of shit all at once so you don’t have to do it manually.
Really the only problem is that it still could fuck up the way it does with information; it might generate a block of nonsense that simply looks good to an amateur.
Art is not meant to be an expression of humanity.
Creativity in general is something anything can do. Human, animal or other wise.
The humanity element is the self expression through art.
The self expression is what makes it “art” as is generally thought of.
But there is absolutely nothing that stops an animal, robot, or act of nature and happen stance from also generating art.
The random whims and circumstances of nature creating a beautiful landscape or a ugly one. Both are in themselves art. But they aren’t human art.
A machine generating a horrifically generic bland and boring copy paste of algorithmically mundane slop or a accidentally beautiful rendering of a sunflower both are their own kinds of art.
But they aren’t HUMAN art.
Nature and machine can’t express themselves, there’s no ego to express. People focus too much on what’s making the art while at the same time absolutely ignoring why they are focusing on it.
I would never say a machine generated picture is the same kind of art as a human. It fundamentally can’t be. Unless a human transformation the picture the machine generated and curates it.
But then you don’t have a machine generated picture you just have human art that used a tool.
Intend and expression are what makes art what it is.
If you only care about the final put put. Then what make it does not matter at all.
And for some things that is fine. If you need a flat simple UI to do a functional job. That doesn’t need an artist, it needs a product. And machine or human can both make a product.
So in the episode where data plays poker with Einstein, Newton, and Hawking, whose families get paid what royalties for all of them being there?
In that future, there is no money so nobody gets paid anything. You’ve enriched the human experience and that’s reward enough.
You can’t eat exposure.
Just use the replicator; it’s free.
Except all of them lived before ST:TNG, except Hawking. I’m sure Hawking was consensually compensated. I do feel like after that episode, Hawking did get a little celebrity-dom.
Right and Hawking’s estate owns his likeness
Well if the fruit fly brain experiment is any indication, and if the Amazing Digital Circus is any prediction of how far it’ll go, we shouldn’t be too far away from being faced with artificial sapient rights as well



















