The power of context is truly remarkable. Max Fosh convinces coffee nerds that the worst coffee possible, is actually nice.
I am quite annoyed by this, since I know from experience how big the difference is between expensive and cheap coffee.
I’m guessing it was serving it cold that made the trick plausible. Or is it true what normies think of coffee people? That coffee is just coffee, it’s not that deep. I disagree personally.
From experience, you adjust to your taste and the taste adjusts to you. Each time i’m used to some alternative and/or mix, coffee pure is disgusting. Every time i’m used to espresso, the alternative is bland.
I agree. That’s why I keep drinking the regular coffee at the office so I don’t get too picky eventually.
As noted in the comments, running the coffee through a nitrous oxide whipper is doing a lot more than just cooling it. In addition of the placebo effect of the presentation and being filmed. Also any bad reactions can be cut out and people will line up just for the novelty even if they were told it doesn’t actually taste good.
The base idea is fun: how and to what extent you can mask the taste of bad coffee, but the execution is mean spirited hyperbole.
Yeah I wonder what nitrous does to the taste. I’ve never had it so I can only imagine it being somewhat similar to a Guinness. However the video wasn’t that mean spirited and clearly has a comedic tone to it. I thought it was fun.
It’s entertainment
There are tiers of coffee and there are not hard rules about what establishment fits where, beans, brew method etc play a big par. I’ve had bad at a dedicated coffee shop. I’ve had good at an automated machine.
Do I really need a wannabe with a YT voice to tell me that. Calling people Coffee ‘snobs’ and implying they can’t taste difference in quality is simply shitstirring for the screen.
Some additional notes to add:
The video is actually really funny. And James Hoffman is in it!
I don’t like the thumbnail either.
The coffee convention he was “infiltrating” didn’t seem like a super serious specialty coffee thing. The people that were tricked seemed more like laymen than actually coffee professionals. I think there’s no way in hell you could fool an actual expert with that coffee.
The coffee came from a random car mechanics poorly maintained automated coffee machine, it looked like actual shit. So it’s not even from a gas station, which would’ve been way better coffee actually. Just wanted to mention for those that didn’t watch the video.
Almost all coffee I’ve ever had in rich countries is burnt to shit. You might as well put straight carbon in a paper filter and pour water over it.
Properly roasted coffee is most often a bit sweet, fruity, acidic, and perhaps chocolaty. Over-roasting turns essential acidity into bitterness.
Starbucks convinced everyone that liquid ash is fit for human consumption. I’m no barista or roaster, but I intuitively know I don’t want to chew on a burnt log at the bottom of a campfire.
Depends on your preference. I actually like dark roast and not a fan of blonde or med roast. And honestly I only drink espressos, so starbucks is usually good and consistent. Most mom and pop shops make their espressos too bitter for me.
I also prefer dark roast, but I agree that Starbucks tastes burnt.
Definitely a matter of taste. Enjoy it!
Espressos are entirely lost on me. Surely it has its place if so many people love it, but to me it doesn’t taste like coffee.
It’s the farming and the farmer’s initial processing that provides the magic that I enjoy. Try to find coffee beans whose process is named Natural, and whose beans looked slightly toasted, but not dark and oily, then you’ve reached my coffee nirvana. Too many roasters would take those glorious beans and char them beyond chemical recognition.
Definitely a matter of taste. I’ve found for my personal tastes, as you can see by going through my post history here, the best tasting coffee in the world is low pressure light roasted espresso. I love other coffee too but that combo is just pure heaven in my mouth. It’s commonly called “soup” in the online espresso world, and I’m a massive fan. I do also really enjoy traditional espresso too (usually with medium roast beans), just not quite as much.
My wife hates soup. Everyone’s different. She prefers medium roast americanos, which I personally really don’t enjoy. It’s important to find your perfect drink.
Never heard of “soup”. Interesting. I like your idea of finding one’s perfect drink. Making excellent coffee is my first move every day. I couldn’t imagine life without it. Luckily, I don’t need to.
Soup started on the Espresso Aficionados discord group. It was originally called piss shots actually, but when people were enjoying it the name needed to change. It’s an acronym for ‘Spro, Only UnPressurized. Anyway, it became a bit of a meme but it turns out that it’s actually a great way to make coffee if you have the right equipment for it. You need either a manual espresso maker or a machine with pressure profiling, because it requires a preinfusion and a very low pressure shot pull. A normal 9-bar machine will just give you either super sour espresso if you grind it normally or a really terrible under-extracted shot if you grind coarse.
The final cup should be around 3-4x the weight of the beans you put in, in around 15 seconds, there should be no crema, and it should be really acidic (but not sour), with tons of fruity flavours. The lighter the roast the better for soup. It’s not even really espresso at that point but it’s really good. If you’re curious to learn more, I’ve made a post about it here.
The premises BS. Plenty of gas stations have pretty decent coffee. Some even have good coffee.
Coffee doesn’t need to be expensive or exotic or anything else to be good. It just needs to be made well.
Did you watch the video? It’s from his local garage that’s a coffee vending machine that also serves vegetable soup.
These days, gas station coffee is brewed on the spot from a machine most of the time. Back when it was a pot on a burner plate, that shit would get burnt to all hell and back.
It certainly could get burned, but if you were there early in the morning, particularly at a busy gas station where people regularly stopped on their way out to work, that shit would be extremely fresh.
Yep. Temperature control is key. To hot, it tastes bitter. To cold, no taste. I find if you leave a bit of water in the pot when you start. Less likely to make a bad cup. The keep warm element burns that first little bit spoiling the whole pot.
Hmm I thought I’d perfected my morning brew ritual, but I’ve never tried leaving a little water in carafe. I’ll try tomorrow! Start with just a splash? Or enough to cover the bottom? How do you do it?
Also, give the pot a swirl after. It’s done brewing. We’ll it depends. I drink black, no sugar. My wife has hers with cream. The first cup pour is typicaly of won’t be as strong and bitter alot easier drinking black so I take that one. Because of a lot of the solids, settle out a quick stir, and the flavor becomes more even, especially if you drink more than one cup.
I keep about just about 1/2" /13mm
My personal favorite:

Found it on a road trip, in a gas station in Florida. Was so delicious, I went back in to get more, and a t-shirt.
They have excellent kona
Gas station coffee may have been decent when it was brewed but it’s ruined by sitting on the hot plate for hours.
I haven’t been to a gas station with a filter brewer and a hot plate coffee for years. Nowadays they all have bean to cup machines. As long as it’s cleaned regularly and gets enough traffic, so the beans don’t go stale, they are usually decent.
That slop thumbnail is a huge no from me
Only the blurry background may be photoshop generative fill. His videos are high quality, I just think he outsources his thumbnails, but provides the source images he wants.
When art moves away from greed imitating art
We need a filter
- slopnail with a prominent shit stirring head and ‘claimesque’ bold title.
- thread title posing it as an inquisitive question
- Video posted with no write up.
If it’s 2 out of 3 - or should be outta here.
TbF it would have been really hard to find a table, pot of coffe, a gas station, and a person to setup an actual photo. That’s probably hollywood level budget right there, not something a random YouTuber could do.
Haha I didn’t get the joke for a second, but I chuckled once I did 😆
I recently discovered through Lemmy the extension Dearrow which removes the awful fake thumnails. I love it so much not seeing that crap anymore.
I leave the thumbnails on so I know which channels are using slop. It helps me avoid them.
That’s my exact thought. If the thumbnails are shit I would like to know.
Knew a wine connoisseur that would sometimes do it with wine, he invented stuff, like he could say “this wine reminds me of some ceylan pepper” and the other people were like “yes you are right, ceylan pepper!” even if ceylan pepper does not exist.
It reminds me of the John Cleese’s 2004 documentary, “Wine for the Confused”. He invites his friends, including Brendan Fraser, to a blind wine tasting. Many couldn’t tell the difference between red and white wine, nor could they determine which were the fancy expensive wines. Basically wine is good.
Anyone can tell the difference between Arabica and robusta.
lol my dad used to do this at vineyards. The best he ever got someone to go along with was bread & butter pudding.
I’m not a coffee nerd, but bad coffee is terrible stuff. Note that I tend to have my cream and sugar with a little coffee, and I pickup that the typical stuff at a gas station leaves some fowl afternotes.
just playing devils advocate here, see my other coment, but this could also be due to bad/dirty equipment. A cheap, lower quality coffee still tastes a million times better freshly roasted (1-2 weeks off roast), ground with a good grinder, brewed on clean equipment than the same coffee 4 months off roast, ground with a bad grinder (uneven grounds, lots of boulders and fines), brewed on dirty equipment.
Coffee oils oxidize quickly and become rancid. They accumulate in a sticky, tar-like, black substance that is bitter and disgusting.
coffe has more aromatic compounds than wine. Everyone who thinks that coffee is just coffee and specialty coffee nerds are just pretending doesn’t know what they are talking about.
Coffee roasters wouldn’t need to do cuppings and wouldn’t need to bring sample roasters to coffee farms to sample the coffee. They wouldn’t need to travel to different farms that produce different varieties at different elevations with different soil conditions. Farmers wouldn’t need to research and develop different processing methods. Roasters wouldn’t need instruments to measure moisture content in coffee beans and roast level metrics, to create reproducible roast profiles.
All of the above are things the consumer doesn’t see and in most cases doesn’t even know about. So from a business point of view those things would be a huge waste of money if it didn’t impact the flavour.
I think you’re correct.
I met a coffee farmer just last week who was saying that the old way of testing moisture in beans was done was biting softly on them, that it had been done that way for centuries, and that it’s still quite accurate compared to modern machines. Then he bit into a bean right in front of me and said it had 12% humidity before testing it in a machine that confirmed his belief.
Our rightful hatred of capitalism has us (including me) jump to the conclusion that EVERYTHING is marketing bullshit, because it sooooo often is, including with coffee, but there is also a deep expertise underlying it that rich country coffee drinkers never think about because they never see it. They just want their coffee from a trendy coffee shop so they can post it on Instagram, and they assume it’s high quality because they’ve been taught that a brand somehow imparts quality.
When my geography allows it, I get my coffee either directly from farmers, or from very small roasters who literally go pick it up directly from farmers. There is zero exaggeration in the previous sentence. Those who haven’t tasted such quality would easily be fooled by some jackass with gas station coffee.
Last note in this rant, it’s the beans and how they’re grown that matters. It’s the type of processing done to the beans by farmers that matters (washed, honey, natural). The job of the roasters in rich countries is not to fuck up all that meticulous hard work, yet they almost always do. These growers have deep expertise. I’ve seen their processes with my own eyes, although I’m too dumb to understand all the intricacies.
The whole specialty coffee world is such a niche market that it is, at least in my opinion, vastly occupied by enthusiasts that work in this field not because they want to make money but because they are passionate about coffee. They also usually try to use fair(er) supply chains and (try to?!) minimize unequal exchange. Profit margins are much smaller in specialty coffee because of this.
The bigger industrial roasters work by other incentives. I wouldn’t say that they fuck it up because of incompetence though. They usually use lower quality coffee in the first place and then roast them darker because their main goal is consistency rather than exaggeration of origin characteristics. They then use manipulative marketing to hide all the shitty stuff they have to do to get to the cheaper and more consistent end product (essentially pretending they’d do all the stuff the specialty coffee roasters actually do).
But in general i’ll have to admit that coffee drinking the way we in the global north do is very unsustainable. I usually try to buy raw beans directly, roast them myself and drink less but better coffee, rather than a lot. I am very passionate about coffee but i once estimated the amount of coffee plants i would personally need to sustain my own coffee consumption and let’s just say i’d need a pretty big garden …
Whilst I do think conscientious farmers are the best thing, the humidity story could be an easy trick. He could’ve measured before and then ‘tasted it by the chewing method’.
I mean marketing bullshit isn’t only perpetrated by big business only.
I get what you’re saying, but that wasn’t the case here. He walked in late to a presentation and as some beans were being passed around, he randomly grabbed one and told us about the biting method. Also, he wasn’t there to sell anything.
TBF, wine makers have done a LOT of things for centuries that customers didn’t know about and turned out to be useless too.
True but that is true for all sorts of explortations. Sometimes you throw shit at the wall and see what sticks. There are a lot of things in coffee as well that used to be best practices and are now considered useless, outright negative or just not proven to do anything yet. Variable RPM in electric grinders comes to mind. Afaik nobody knows for sure whether that does anything. Especially in espresso making there are a lot of unsubstantiated and sometimes even detrimental takes on how to prepare the puck correctly. This is probably partially due to the fact that those products are so widely available and it is somewhat easy to experiment with them. You cannot expect rigorous scientific explorations from everyone though.
There are, however, also peer reviewed, scientific studies done on both coffee and wine and there is more general knowledge about chemical and biological processes involved in processing and growing coffee and wine that we have a good understanding of. So not everything is pseudo science and smoke and mirrors.
This is a weird amount of comments about some dumb click bait bullshit video
Max Fosh is actually really high quality. His antics are more than just “well we did this” as he got a coffee expert to tell him how to make the shitty coffee slightly better like cooking it down immediately and even using nitro.
Agree. I’m adding another at this stage.
I don’t believe this is plausible.
Gimme that Wawa coffee
Take as much as you’d like.
Pax & beneficia is some of the best coffee ive ever had.
Well McDonald’s $1 cup is better than most other convenience coffee, and I’m sure they don’t pay a lot for the beans.
















