Founder of European Graphic Novels, Aug '23 on Lemm.ee. Still going strong, now on PieFed. :D

I prefer to lean friendly & understanding, yet as someone dealing with a terminal disease, I’ll admit that irritability can happen fast. Eh, nous faisons ce que nous pouvons. 🙄

  • 57 Posts
  • 2.14K Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2025

help-circle










  • There are even other sets of Judaism that followed other messiahs into their own faction besides Jesus.

    Hmm, that’s interesting. Rosacrucians wouldn’t figure in to that, would they?

    You can actually learn about his life, to an extent, which you can’t really do if you just assume he didn’t exist.

    That’s not really what I’m proposing, though. What I’m saying is that not unlike Robin Hood and King Arthur, there may have been more than one person from the contemporary period (given latitude) that might have been swept up in to the personae of “Jesus.”

    For example, “Thomas the twin” seems to be considered a twin brother of Yeshua ben Yosef in various traditions, and imagine how that might have worked. You know, the “resurrection” and all? But there are countless possibilities with just that, not to speak of various contemporaneous people of the time who resembled Yeshua somewhat, preached somewhat similar messages, and got gathered up in to the web of the story.

    They all might well have gotten laundered in to a single person, is what I’m proposing. As we’ve seen countless times before.

    EDIT: I mean no hurt or unkindness. My teacher is Joseph Campbell, who embraced all traditions & peoples, FWIW.


  • A baby who may never have existed in the first place, far as I know.

    Christianity scholars will argue that the surviving documents suggest that there was some kind of a person who was later rebranded as “Jesus Christ,” but I’d counter that who knows if it was a single, discrete person? Like many (most?) legendary figures, it could have been formed out of a composite of real-life figures overlaid with the myths that surround them, often borrowing from earlier legends as well. And all we really have are folk tales about this ‘person’ that were passed down from storyteller to storyteller and finally written down up to hundreds of years later. Later, *some* of those tales that fit a certain agenda were collected in to a ‘holy book’ for the ages.

    OTOH, societies and peoples are unified and controlled by shared beliefs, so if it wasn’t this set of fairy tales, it would almost certainly be another. I wonder what that might have looked like?